Thursday, June 15, 2006

Debate

Help me out; what bike component group should I get:

a. Campagnolo Record
b. Campagnolo Chorus
c. Shimano Dura Ace
d. Shimano Ultegra

10 comments:

Trisaratops said...

Gesundheit.

E-Speed said...

umm cycling dumb. no clue. But I think Shimano Ultegra :)

Janet Edwards said...

Yeah, that one!

Eric said...

Ultegra. I run an Ultegra rear deraileur for sure. The other parts are 105 because they don't get that much use and don't save me that much. On my road bike I also have Ultegra on the brakehood/shifters. Oh an my cranks are Ultegra. 105 pedals on the tri bike, ultegra pedals on the road bike.

anything else you want to know?

Trifrog said...

You buying a bike where you get a choice? Nice! Or are you just buying a whole new set for your current ride? Nicer!

I've wanted a sexy Italian road bike for a long time, so I say go with Campy.

But I've always heard that the top of the line is not worth the upcharge from the next-to-the-top. I've never had the opportunity to find out, so I'm just passing on the advice.

That said, I like my Ultegra with Cervelo knock-offs better than I like my 105 group.

Chris said...

Campy if you want to be different.
DA if you just got a bonus.
Ultegra if you want the best value.

I have full DA on my bike (well, I have a compact crankset on with a DA crankset in my closet :P). But if I had to go and buy parts from scratch again, I'd probably buy Ultegra. I'm not fast enough to deserve DA. :)

If you don't mind mixing and matching, I might do Ultegra everywhere except maybe the rear derailleur. And the crankset, because the DA cranks are just damn sexy. :)

Papa Louie said...

Grams to dollars. performance to dollars. Marketing. Too many choices.
Rob probably makes the most sense. But then so does everyone else.

RunBubbaRun said...

I like the Ultegra componets on my TRi bike and have DA'on my road bike..The weight is minmal I have found and yeah spend the bucks on a good wheel set..They make your ride look sweet...

Kewl Nitrox said...

My vote goes to Ultegra for the same reasons mentioned above - best value for money and works well. Betta to spend the $$ on something else that will make more of a difference like race wheels...

BTW, I use 105. So Ultegra is plenty good. DuraAce is really overkill in my books.

Anonymous said...

Shimano, for sure...just like everyone else said...

thanks for the well-wishes...sorry i'm so late with catching up on your blog!